The sting of a new higher federal cigarette tax is burning a little early at most local convenience stores, and the pain to the pocketbook probably is only going to get worse.
Ask Daryl Johnson, who has seen his favorite Newport brand jump more than a dollar to $5.02 – and it’s still more than a week until the 62-cent per-pack federal increase kicks in on April 1.
“I think I might have to stop smoking,” Johnson said while standing inside the BP service station on York Street.
For a one-pack-a-day smoker, that 62 cents adds up to about $4.34 week or about $226 a year.
“It’s going to cause people to pick up another habit or basically start buying them by the carton,” said Johnson, who has been a smoker since he was 16.
Right now, the federal cigarette tax is 39 cents per pack, making the new federal tax $1.01. The additional funds will go to the State Children’s Health Insurance Program, a federal/state insurance program which aims to expand health coverage to children whose families make too much to qualify for Medicaid but too little to purchase private insurance. But that’s likely to be just the first of it for South Carolina smokers.
The state General Assembly is considering a 50 cent per pack increase to 57 cents, and this year it looks like the increase has a good chance of passing. That brings that same pack of cigarettes up to $5.52.
The push to raise the state’s cigarette tax, now the lowest in the country by 10 cents per pack, has been hard-fought over several years. Last year, Gov. Mark Sanford vetoed the increase and promises to do so again if the increase doesn’t have a corresponding tax decrease. Because the House was divided on how to spend the additional money, it couldn’t muster enough votes to override the veto.
Now, both sides of the House think they have a compromise bill that they can agree on, said House Speaker Bobby Harrell.
Harrell, a Republican from Charleston, has modeled the plan after an Oklahoma program that uses the cigarette tax revenue to get matching federal funds. That federal money would be used to give tax credits to small businesses to help provide insurance for low-income people.
The plan proposed last year was objectionable because it expanded Medicare, he said.
The new plan is driven by the private sector and gives tax credits for small businesses to provide health insurance. The business would receive a tax credit, which would cover about 75 percent of its cost of buying the insurance. Employees also could get the credit if their employer opts not to buy health insurance, he said.
The additional 50-cent tax would generate about $150 million a year. That would be matched 2-to-1 by the federal government, which means the benefit to the state is about $450 million a year. The insurance program would apply to people earning 200 percent of the federal poverty level, Harrell said. That’s $21,660 for an individual or $44,100 for a family of four. Those scales could be adjusted.
Harrell said Oklahoma was able to take advantage of the matching funds by applying for a specific waiver. Since the South Carolina plan follows that plan, he is confident the state could get those same funds.
The new plan also provides about $5 million for smoking cessation efforts. The state currently puts no money toward that.
Harrell expects the bill to be approved by the House and the Senate. He doesn’t know if the governor will veto it, but he’s confident there would be the votes to override it.
But whatever happens, smokers will pay the price.
Doris Hightower, the assistant manager of the Circle K convenience store on East Pine Log Road, has been alerting customers who purchase cigarettes in her store for weeks that prices will soon go up. Customer reactions have been mixed, she said.
“It’s kind of crazy; I don’t really understand it,” Circle K customer Jonathan Whiten said of the increase. He said the tax increase probably won’t make him stop smoking, but rather he’ll switch to a cheaper brand.
“Smokers are always the easy targets,” said Darnell Peterson, who said he has smoked for about 10 years. “When it’s time to take away rights or raise taxes, we are always picked on.”
Though Peterson said the increase will make his habit more expensive, he doesn’t plan to quit anytime soon.
“I refuse to let the government run my life,” he said.
Smoking by the Numbers
$4 – a typical price for a pack of cigarettes around Aiken **
$4.90 – average cost with the additional 62 cent federal tax **
$5.40 – average cost if SC adds additional 50 cent state tax
Increased costs for a one-pack-a-day smoker with new federal and proposed 50 cent state tax increase
$1.12 per day
$7.84 per week
$407.68 per year
7 cents – the lowest per-pack state cigarette tax – South Carolina
17 cents – the 2nd lowest per-pack cigarette tax – Missouri
$2.75 – the highest per-pack state cigarette tax – New York
$4.25 – what New York City smokers pay in state and city per pack taxes
$1.21 average state cigarette tax
$32.1 million – amount SC collected in cigarette tax in 2006, the 5th lowest in the country