Increasing tax on cigarettes will not help solve “challenges” in the federal budget’s bottom line, Treasurer Wayne Swan says.

Last week, Treasury confirmed to a Senate estimates hearing that the coalition’s proposal to increase tobacco taxes would save $300 million more than means testing the private health insurance rebate.

Opposition Leader Malcolm Turnbull has put forward a plan to raise the excise on tobacco by 12.5 per cent.

Mr Swan defended Labor’s decision not to implement a higher tobacco tax.

“Malcolm Turnbull… was somehow suggesting that an increase in tobacco tax was an answer to some structural challenges in the budget,” he told Network Ten on Sunday.

“It is not, and he got that entirely wrong.”

Copyright © 2009 News.smh